Synthesise data from a single evaluation

To develop evaluative judgments, the evaluator draws data from the evaluation and systematically synthesises and values the data. There are a range of options that can be used for synthesis and valuing.

Options

Processes

  • Consensus Conference: a process where a selected group of lay people (non-experts) representing the community are briefed, consider the evidence and prepare a joint finding and recommendation
  • Expert Panel: a process where a selected group of experts consider the evidence and prepare a joint finding

Techniques

  • Cost Benefit Analysis: compares costs to benefits, both expressed in monetary units
  • Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: compares costs to the outcomes expressed in terms of a standardized unit (eg additional years of schooling)
  • Cost Utility Analysis: a particular type of cost-effectiveness analysis that expresses benefits in terms of a standard unit such as Quality Adjusted Life Years
  • Global Assessment Scales: providing an overall rating of performance across multiple dimensions.
  • Lessons learnt: Lessons learnt can develop out of the evaluation process as evaluators reflect on their experiences in undertaking the evaluation.
  • Multi-Criteria Analysis: a systematic process to address multiple criteria and perspectives
  • Numeric Weighting: developing numeric scales to rate performance against each evaluation criterion and then add them up for a total score.
  • Qualitative Weight and Sum: using qualitative ratings (such as symbols) to identify performance in terms of essential, important and unimportant criteria
  • Rubrics: using a descriptive scale for rating performance that incorporates performance across a number of criteria
  • Value for Money: a term used in different ways, including as a synonym for cost-effectiveness, and as systematic approach to considering these issues throughout planning and implementation, not only in evaluation.

Approaches:

  • Social Return on Investment: a systematic way of incorporating social, environmental, economic and other values into decision-making processes

 

 

Comments

There are currently no comments. Be the first to comment on this page!

Add new comment

Login Login and comment as BetterEvaluation member or simply fill out the fields below.